I agree, there were Role Play responses... and if this had been handled in ANY WAY like a role playing situation, then none of this would have happened. It never would have gotten to this situation. Let's just make it clear then.
Stranger named 1138 initiates the conversation. The character tag is nothing other than 1138.
1138 - nice ship you have there
1138 - did you get permission to purchase it?
Cygna - Since CFPD isn't on the server any more, it's kind of hard to get permission
1138 - Sure they are, they just aren't tagged
Hawkinz - Then they are violating the rules, since all clan members must be tagged
1138 - Oh, we got a smart mouth here. Don't quote the rules to me, I wrote most of them.
Hawkinz - I'm a smart mouth for repeating what is in big red letters outside Manhattan?
1138 - I'm going to kill you for mouthing off to me.
Now, that is abbreviated, but that's how it went. Not once did he identify himself. His responses weren't Role Play. He wasn't acting the Tough Cop. There are no Under Cover cops, nor are there rules that allow them to be in "Plain Clothes" or out of uniform. He even implies that he is well aware of others running around on the server not wearing their clan tags. This wasn't about egging him on. This wasn't about stolen ships.
In fact, this wasn't the first time an issue has popped up regarding clans taking action against others, without actually being on the server when the offense happened.
***PX Warning to UR on breach of Peace Treaty***
Sure CFPD is taking a break. Unfortunately, just as in that thread there, there are far more UNANSWERED posts about CFPD being no more, than there are about CFPD just taking a break.
I also still remind everyone... if CFPD was taking a break from being an active clan... then they were TAKING A BREAK. They therefore give up the right to say anything. It doesn't matter if they are still paying $30 a month ($20 euros, right?) for their system. They called a big Time Out. The game fines players if they decide to take a Mini Time out... if you hit F1 while you are in combat, you have to pay for it... so there is precedent that taking a time out comes with penalties. CFPD told everyone that they didn't want to play no more... doesn't matter if it was just "Until Further Notice". No one announced that the CFPD break was over... so there is no reason whatsoever why anyone should acknowledge any CFPD characters ACTING LIKE CFPD on or off the server. By their own admission they are taking a break. That's what taking a break means... it means they are stepping out of it. They aren't part of it. That means they aren't playing for the time being. You take a break at work, you don't get paid, and you don't have to work.
But what I'm hearing, is that the rules don't really apply in this case. I mean, Abras stood up for the rules, but otherwise I'm told there are subtleties and nuances here I don't understand?
QuoteFirst, CFPD is still renting it's system so it is still considered an Active Clan even tho not much CFPD pilots a flying around
No. it's not Even Though there aren't many CFPD flying around... they might be renting a system, but they declared they were TAKING A BREAK and STEPPING AWAY FROM PLAYING. That is completely different from the number of active members on the server dropping due to other duties in RL stepping in the way.
QuoteSecond, 1138, as a CFPD member on hiatus, is acting like an ally of CFPD and has been given the powers to enforce the Redemption property rights.
Show me the post. At one point in the conversation, Gunny was quite proud of the fact that he only had 4 hours of play on that 1138 character. So, show me the forum post that proves you out on this.
QuoteThird, yup he's got a smart mouth... I suggest you don't bite too hard tho cause he is teasing you for fun.
He wasn't teasing. He was angry. He was angry because some guy he didn't know from Adam was quoting the rules to him. He made that clear by IMMEDIATELY getting insulting at that point. He made that clear by boasting about how he didn't need to know the rules because he wrote them. He was angry because he wasn't getting the respect he thought he deserved... and before you say anything about GUNNY deserving respect, this was all happening with some "1138" not Gunny.