Suggestion: Improve the Police Role and Balance Police vs Pirates

There are 15 replies in this Thread. The last Post () by Elk1989.

  • Hello everyone,

    I would like to suggest some changes to the Police role on the Crossfire server.

    After playing Crossfire for a while, I have noticed that the Pirate role seems to be much more attractive and much more commonly played than Police.

    The Pirate role has a very clear advantage: a pirate can actively tax other players and generate income from the role. Police, on the other hand, have the responsibility of hunting pirates and dealing with illegal activities, but there does not seem to be a comparable combat advantage that would make the Police role attractive, especially for newer players.

    A new or inexperienced police player often can't easily compete against an experienced pirate who has a lot of PvP experience.


    My suggestions:

    1. A special Police ship

    Introduce a ship that can only be purchased/used by players with a Police License.

    The ship could have a small combat advantage, for example:

    slightly better shields;

    slightly better armor;

    better weapon range;

    access to a special Police weapon;

    or another unique Police-only equipment.

    The purpose would not be to make Police overpowered, but to give them the tools necessary to actually confront experienced pirates.

    2. Police-exclusive equipment

    Another possibility would be special Police equipment instead of, or in addition to, a special ship. For example, a Police weapon, missile or shield that gives the Police a moderate advantage against pirates.

    The goal would be that when a pirate encounters a Police officer, the pirate has a real reason to think twice instead of simply attacking the officer.

    3. Make the Police License permanent on the ship

    I would also suggest making the Police/Pirate license a permanent choice for a ship.

    Once a Police License or Pirate License is installed on a ship, it should remain permanently attached to that ship and should only be removed when the ship is sold.

    This would make choosing a role an actual decision instead of something that can be changed whenever it becomes convenient.

    The goal is not to make Police stronger than Pirates. The goal is to create a better balance between the two roles and encourage more players to actually play Police.

    At the moment, the Pirate role appears to dominate the server, while active Police players seem to be much rarer.

    I would be interested to hear what the community and staff think about these ideas. Maybe there are already Police advantages that I have overlooked, or perhaps there are technical limitations that make some of these suggestions impossible.

    And I would be interested in hearing other ideas for improving the Police role.

  • Maybe there are already Police advantages that I have overlooked

    Police license gives more range on the player scanner, while pirate and smuggler license gives you less.

    That's about the only advantage I can think of. But Mercenaries get the same extended scanner range,


    I have played all 4 roles and I generally prefer Mercenary over Police because pirates often have bounties on them. (I'm a lawful mercenary, only going after pirates)

    All you can do as police is fine them like once an hour while they are trying to tax you, and winner gets all.


    As of now, there simply isn't that much incentive to play as police when you want to fight pirates. (correct me if I'm wrong, but I believe you can't fine them until they tax someone)

    What might help is giving police the ability to collect bounties from pirates, so they don't have to choose between police and mercenary RP. (but maybe do not let pirates collect bounties from police. Or maybe do, most bounties on police are from pirates anyway)

    Edited 2 times, last by Apache ().

  • While understandable the suggestions are technically very tricky to do. The game engine has limitations and restricting ships and equipment is one of them.

    signew.jpg


    cfmoddblogo.png5904.png5904.png
    http://www.moddb.com/scripts/topsite.php?ts=4766


    Only dead fish swim with the stream.
    Don't discuss with idiots. They only drag you down to their level and then beat you with experience there.


    This is ten percent luck,
    Twenty percent skill,
    Fifteen percent concentrated power of will,
    Five percent pleasure,
    Fifty percent pain,
    And a hundred percent reason to remember the name!

  • Technically, it’s probably only possible to give the police an advantage using licensing properties. And perhaps the only reason to play as the police is to get revenge on the pirates. Pirates are usually very experienced and well‑armed veterans of the game. It’s hard to stand up to them alone, and even if you’re able to stand up to them just as well, that doesn’t scare them at all — a small fine once an hour doesn’t bother them. Besides, you also have to defeat them and prevent them from escaping. A police clan could give the police an advantage, but there aren’t enough players on the server for that.

  • The confrontattion difficulty is what causes the imbalance.

    Pirates can take benefit from taxing weak players and traders, while Police essentially always face a pirate with more or less combat experience. The chances that Police players ever encounter a conflict situation with a almost defenseless player is almost non-existent.

    Thats the origin of this imbalance.

    signew.jpg


    cfmoddblogo.png5904.png5904.png
    http://www.moddb.com/scripts/topsite.php?ts=4766


    Only dead fish swim with the stream.
    Don't discuss with idiots. They only drag you down to their level and then beat you with experience there.


    This is ten percent luck,
    Twenty percent skill,
    Fifteen percent concentrated power of will,
    Five percent pleasure,
    Fifty percent pain,
    And a hundred percent reason to remember the name!

  • Technically, it’s probably only possible to give the police an advantage using licensing properties. And perhaps the only reason to play as the police is to get revenge on the pirates. Pirates are usually very experienced and well‑armed veterans of the game. It’s hard to stand up to them alone, and even if you’re able to stand up to them just as well, that doesn’t scare them at all — a small fine once an hour doesn’t bother them. Besides, you also have to defeat them and prevent them from escaping. A police clan could give the police an advantage, but there aren’t enough players on the server for that.

    Yup, that's why I gave up on Police RP and switched to mercenary. As police, you only get one shot at collecting your fine.

    But if you are a merc going after a pirate with a bounty, you can afford to lose the first round, get taxed, and then come back until you win, even if it takes you 100 times, and eventually collect this bounty.


    Simple solution: if a police officer kills a pirate that has a bounty, he should get the bounty for his trouble.

    And if that sounds unfair to the pirate, make it go both ways.


    By the way, I'm not in favour of giving police players stronger ships, absolutely not.

    I just think there should be a little more incentive for players to pick the police role over (lawful) mercenary.

    Edited 3 times, last by Apache ().

  • There’s an idea — to automatically assign a bounty for pirate heads for any players except pirates. The more violations, the higher the bounty. I think this is technically feasible.

  • There’s an idea — to automatically assign a bounty for pirate heads for any players except pirates. The more violations, the higher the bounty. I think this is technically feasible.

    Make that just for police players and it's perfect. It's about incentive to play the role.


    Smugglers incentive is of course large profits.

    Pirates incentive is a guaranteed tax from anyone that isn't flying a top-of-the-line fighter.

    Mercenaries incentive is that bounties are a guaranteed payout, you only have to win once, and you can take as many times as it takes.

    Police incentive? Fining smugglers, maybe, but it is very hard to catch a smuggler with contraband. Most of the time I see one, they are empty or have legal cargo. Can't fine them for that.

    When it comes to fighting pirates as police, there's little incentive either. Your odds are 50/50 to win a fine or lose a tax in the first fight. And whether you win or lose, it's only one fight worth of incentive, after that there's no incentive to keep fighting them, because no one is paying you. It's more viable to be mercenary and wait until someone puts a bounty on your pirate target.

    Edited 2 times, last by Apache ().

  • I should note that the bounty hasn’t been working lately. We’ve checked a couple of times. And the smuggling routes and many smugglers are well known — you can catch them)) though I’m a smuggler myself and I’m not interested in that. DD

  • In my eyes, this sounds less like balancing and more like asking for official, role-based cheats :roflmao:

  • 👮 Making Police worth it

    A proposal based on your ideas in this thread


    The main problem is not that police ships are too weak. The problem is that police has too little reason to hunt pirates.

    Stronger police ships or weapons would only start the next balance discussion. So here is my idea:



    💰 1. Police can collect bounties

    Today only pilots with a mounted Mercenary license can collect a bounty.

    ➡️ We could also allow the Police license too.



    🏴‍☠️ 2. Automatic "Wanted" bounty on pirates

    • Every time a pirate gets a tax paid, he gets +1 Wanted level.
    • A part of the tax (for example 20 %) does not go to the pirate. It goes into a bounty on his head.
    • Only police can collect this bounty by shooting the pirate down.
    • The more a pirate taxes, the higher his Wanted level and the more he is worth.
    • If the pirate stays quiet for a while, the Wanted level goes down again.


    Quote

    Example:

    A pirate taxes 5 traders for 1,000,000 credits each.

    ➡️ He keeps 4,000,000 credits.

    ➡️ 1,000,000 credits are waiting on his head – for the police officer who catches him. 🎯


    Why this way?

    • ✅ No new money is created – it comes from the taxes.
    • ✅ Police always has a target that is worth it, even if nobody places a bounty.
    • ✅ Pirates can still play like before. Very active pirates just become valuable prey.



    📜 3. Higher fine for wanted pirates

    A pirate with a high Wanted level pays a higher fine.

    And /fine shows you the Wanted level of your target.



    📊 Before and after

    TodayWith this idea
    Police collects bounties❌✅
    Bounty without a player placing it❌✅ (Wanted)
    Fine depends on pirate activity❌✅
    Stronger police ships❌❌ (on purpose)



    🔧 About "the bounty is not working"

    Some bugs in the bounty system were fixed and the fixes are already on the server.

    If a bounty is still not paid, please post time, killer and victim – then we can check the logs.

    ⚠️ Important: to collect a bounty, the license must be mounted, not only in the cargo.



    🚀 About police-only ships and equipment

    We can limit ships or items to a license. But the server cannot make them stronger – that would need a mod change, and for balance reasons I don't want to go this way.

    A license that stays on the ship forever is possible, but not easy to do safely. So it is not a "no", just not the first step.



    💬 Your opinion?

    • How much of the tax should go into the bounty? 20 %? More? Less?
    • How fast should the Wanted level go down?
    • Should pirates also be able to collect bounties on police?


    Fly safe – or fly wanted. 😉

    download.gif

  • I get GTA vibes ;)

    signew.jpg


    cfmoddblogo.png5904.png5904.png
    http://www.moddb.com/scripts/topsite.php?ts=4766


    Only dead fish swim with the stream.
    Don't discuss with idiots. They only drag you down to their level and then beat you with experience there.


    This is ten percent luck,
    Twenty percent skill,
    Fifteen percent concentrated power of will,
    Five percent pleasure,
    Fifty percent pain,
    And a hundred percent reason to remember the name!

  • 1. (Police can collect bounties) Sounds good, and make it both ways between police and pirate. Just don't let police collect bounties from anyone else. We don't want to put mercenaries out of a job.

    2 + 3. (Wanted system) sounds good too, I was thinking anywhere between 10-20% with a duration of 1-3 days, same as most bounties.

    4. Police-exclusive ships, equipment and sticky licenses: please no. I don't think police need stronger ships, I just think they needed more incentive to stay with the police, instead of defecting to the Bounty Hunters Guild. (I am currently flying as Mercenary, but I only bountyhunt pirates, I don't think that is how Mercenary is supposed to be)

  • Thanks a lot, that's very helpful!


    Based on your feedback, here is the updated idea:


    1. Bounties between police and pirates

    To keep the mercenaries in business, the rules for normal bounties (placed by players) would be:

    • Mercenary: can collect bounties from everyone (like today)
    • Police: can collect bounties from pirates only
    • Pirate: can collect bounties from police only


    2. Wanted system

    • A pirate becomes "Wanted" when he actually gets money from a tax. This happens if the player pays the tax, or if the pirate shoots the player down (then the tax is paid automatically, like today).
    • Just using /tax does not count. If the player escapes or wins the fight, nothing happens.
    • Killing someone without a tax before does not count either. That is normal PvP.
    • Every paid tax gives +1 Wanted level and adds 10-20 % of the tax to a bounty on the pirate's head.
    • The pirate still gets the full tax. The Wanted bounty is paid by the server, not by the pirate.
    • From a certain Wanted level (for example 2 or 3), the server announces that the pirate is wanted. After that, the Wanted level and the bounty keep growing with every paid tax until police collects it (up to a maximum).
    • Every new paid tax resets the timer. If the pirate stays quiet for 1-3 days, the Wanted level goes back to 0 and the bounty expires.


    3. Police has to arrest the pirate with /fine

    Only police can collect the Wanted bounty, and only with a fine. Just shooting a pirate down is not enough - police should enforce the law, not just hunt.

    • The officer fines the wanted pirate with /fine.
    • If the pirate pays the fine (surrenders), the officer gets the fine and the Wanted bounty.
    • If the pirate fights and gets shot down while the fine is active, the officer also gets the fine and the Wanted bounty.
    • If the pirate logs out to escape, the fine is paid as well, so this does not help him.
    • If an officer shoots down a wanted pirate without a fine, he gets nothing.
    • The bounty goes to the officer who gave the fine.
    • A pirate with a higher Wanted level pays a higher fine, and /fine shows the Wanted level of the target.
    • Today a player cannot get a new fine while an old one is still running (up to 2 hours). For wanted pirates this time would be shorter, so an old fine does not block the hunt.


    4. No police-only ships or sticky licenses

    Agreed. Your own example shows the problem: you fly as a mercenary, but you only hunt pirates. That is exactly the job police should have.


    Any more opinions? Especially from pirates - does this feel fair to you?

    download.gif